September 2025 Book Box Spoilers

I am not sponsored or affiliated with any of these boxes. Additionally, a mention on this wrap-up page does not mean I endorse the box. I am simply providing information.

In the interest of keeping data use down (uploading this many pictures of book covers is extremely costly), I have only provided titles of books. In the case where titles are duplicates with other books, an author has also been provided.

For quick reference, use the find feature (CMD + F for Mac, CTRL + F for Windows) to search for a specific book or box.

Aardvark Book Club

Lucky Day/Coffin Moon/The Wrong Daughter/You Weren't Meant to Be Human/Local Heavens/A Land So Wide/Witch You Would

Allurial by BOTM

Wild Reverence* (duplicate with BOTM Sep 🙄)/The Entanglement of Rival Wizards* (duplicate with Dazzling Bookish and Fae Crate Sept)/Song of the Hell Witch

Authentic Books

The Arcane Society

Aug/Sept: Blood & Steel/Vows & Ruins

Baddies Book Box

When We Lied/Undeniably Enemies

The BC Case Girls of Dark Divine

Belle Book Box

Aug/Sept: Rewrite Our Story/Tempt Our Fate

Book Brewed

Book Brigade Box

Fiction:

Non-fiction:

Bookish & Spice

Fantasy: Curse of Shadows and Thorns

Contemporary: Last Shot/Last Breath

The Book(ish) Box Adult

The Enchanted Greenhouse

The Book(ish) Box Darkly

What Fury Brings

The Book Cove

Aug/Sept: In the Wake of the Wicked

Book in a Box

Soul of Shadow

Book of the Month

Alchemy of Secrets/The Heartbreak Hotel/Discontent/To the Moon and Back/All the Way to the River/Play Nice

Add-ons:

Wild Reverence* (duplicate with Allurial September 🙄)/The Academy

The Broken Binding Fantasy

Fevered Star

The Broken Binding SciFi

Aug/Oct: The Sparrow Duology

The Broken Binding SF&F

Crossroads of Ravens

Buchmädchen

Not in My Book

BücherBüchse

Zauberbüchse: Star Crossed Hearts

Dunkel: Vicious Secret

Liebes: Copenhagen Diaries

Butterfly Book Club

Fantasy: A Wraith Between the Tides

Romance: Shattered Obsession

Caffeine & Legends

The Bone Raiders* (duplicate with TBB SE and FairyLoot Epic)

Coveted Cover

August/September Aetheria: The Last Lost Girl

September/October Nocturna: Nine Minutes/Out of Time

Dazzling Bookish Shop

The Entanglement of Rival Wizards* (duplicate with Allurial and Fae Crate Sept)

Dreamer Whale Boxes

Dryad Book Box

Can't Spell Treason Without Tea

Enchanted Fandom

The Mark of Chaos and Creation

Eternal Embers

Strung Along/Catching Sparks

Eternal Embers: Onyx

Aug-Oct: Chicago Ruthless

Fabled

Midnight: Burn with Me

Moonlight: A Deal with the Shadow King

Nights: The Protector's Temptation

Twilight: A Sea of Song and Sirens

Fae Crate

Adult: The Entanglement of Rival Wizards* (duplicate with Allurial and Dazzling Bookish Sept)

YA: Grave Flowers

FairyLoot Adult

Alchemised

FairyLoot Epic (Quarterly)

The Bone Raiders* (duplicate with TBB SE again 🙄 and Caffeine & Legends Sept)

FairyLoot Romantasy

Metal Slinger

FairyLoot YA

Never Ever After

Fated Romance

The Knotty Omega/Her Knotty Alphas

Fiction Addiction

Closed

Fox & Wit Adult

A Tide of Treason

Foxglove (Fox & Wit Romance)

Honey and Heat

Gold Leaf Book Box (Bi-Monthly)

Goldsboro Crime Collective

Our Beautiful Mess

Goldsboro Prem1er

The Matchbox Girl

GSFF

The Maiden and Her Monster

Indie Book Scene

Inkstone (Quarterly)

Where the Axe is Buried

illumicrate

The Second Death of Locke

illumicrate Afterlight

When I Picture You

illumicrate Evernight

illumicrate Starbright

Jewish Joy

Good Grief

Lilac Library's

Quarterly Box

Dream by the Shadows

Lit Love Box

Forget Me Not/A Killer Motive/Breathe In, Bleed Out/The Heartbreak Hotel* (duplicate with BOTM Sep)/Ride the Wave/Burn Bright/The Women at Ocean's End/The Secret Book Society/Katabasis* (duplicate with IC, OC, TBB SE's and FL Sep Adult)/Suprise Book: The Society of Unknowable Objects

The Locked Library

Main: Mistress of Bones

Forbidden Wing Romantasy: My Big Fat Vampire Wedding

Midnight Whispers

Moonlight Book Box

A Thorn in Every Heart

The Mystic Box

Night Worms

What Hunger/Issues with Authority

Once Upon a Book Club Box Adult

The Last Assignment

Once Upon a Book Club Box YA

Falling Like Leaves

OwlCrate

The Sleepless

OwlCrate Adult

The Deathless One

OwlCrate Quarterly Sub

Romance: Well, Actually

Page & Wick (Bi-Monthly)

Secrets of the Dead by Laura Carter (originally published 2023)

Phoenix Crate (Quarterly)

Calor

Bonus book in the deluxe box:

The Gloaming

Use code: eaterofstories

Rainbow Crate Book Box

House of Frank/To Hive and to Hold

Read Between the Vines

RIP

Satisfiction Box

Live to Serve the Witch

So Many Pages

Romantasy: Dans van Zang en Schaduw

Fantasy: Katabasis

To Bee Read by LitJoy

Quarterly: Next box—November

Twisted Fantasy

July/Aug/Sept: The Ever King/The Ever Queen

Twisted Fiction

Twisted Retreat

An Evil Premise

*duplicate book with another box